Florence + the machine (based around Florence Welsch) was formed in 2oo7 in London. The genre is similar to Foals, in that both are alternative indie rock, soul, and art rock. However I want to see how males indie artists differ to female indie artists in both music videos, thus i will compare both Spanish Sahara- Foals and Cosmic Love- Florence and the Machine.
The opening shot is of a light bulb. The mis-en-scene displays the light bulb to be flashing to a beat of the song, making it seem that the light bulb is generating music. The beat is similar to a heart-beat. This is similar to "Spanish Sahara" by The Foals as in the video the sequences of the sea move in time to the beat of the song. The soft reds and orange colour in the beginning shot of "cosmic love" sets a calm atmosphere. It has a connotation of autumn and winter through the reds.
The second shot is of florence walking through red autumn leaves, the colours match her hair colour. As she walks through, she moves leaves away from her face, and is looking above the right-hand side of the mis-en-scene. She is wearing a white shirt with a black bow-tie which contrasts with the red leaves (which have a connotation of autumn), and the dark lighting behind her. The clothing has aspects of alternative rock as ties are stereotypically a male item of clothing. There seems to be a light reflecting on her from the direction in which she is looking.
Florence then starts singing the song as beam of light floats down towards her. The lyrics correlate with the on-screen mis-en-scene, "A fallen star, fell from your heart". The beam of light is bright and lightens up the dark scenery surrounding florence.
As the beam of light travels towards Florence's face the lyrics "and landed in my eyes" are sung as the beam of light goes into her eyes. The image is quite shocking and disturbing.
When the beam of light goes into her eyes it lights up the dark scenery. The imagery is quite alarming as she looks like she is in pain due to covering her eyes with force through clenching her hands tightly over her face.
The shot zooms into a close-up of florence's face as she screams. The lyrics "i screamed allowed as it tore through them and now its left me blind". The shot shows the rings on her fingers, which shows the genre- indie. This could be due the quirky style of rings: two are pedant rings with queen heads on them- this is a fashion statement. The red nail narvish goes with the red colours in the mis-en-scene.Florence then starts singing the song as beam of light floats down towards her. The lyrics correlate with the on-screen mis-en-scene, "A fallen star, fell from your heart". The beam of light is bright and lightens up the dark scenery surrounding florence.
As the beam of light travels towards Florence's face the lyrics "and landed in my eyes" are sung as the beam of light goes into her eyes. The image is quite shocking and disturbing.
When the beam of light goes into her eyes it lights up the dark scenery. The imagery is quite alarming as she looks like she is in pain due to covering her eyes with force through clenching her hands tightly over her face.
The mis-en-scene fades out and a close- up of florence's face looking into the camera appears. As florence sings "blind" her eyes sparkle a beam of light, suggesting the beam of light is still in her eyes. Florence is then seen singing in a mirrored box room, with reflections of orange and red lights on the mirror walls. She is wearing all black which contrasts with the warm colours and ambient lighting which surrounds her. In the first few medium close-ups she is seen lying on the floor singing and her movements are similar to someone who is suffering. She then starts moving in a slow dance but it is as if she is a puppet being pulled by strings, suggesting she is trapped. This has negative connotations suggesting a "performing monkey" which dehumanises her making it seem unethical and degrading. The lyrics "The stars, the moon, they have all been blown out you left me in the dark no dawn, no day, I'm always in this twilight in the shadow of your heart" amplify the on-screen action with her being stuck in endless darkness. "Twilight" could mean everything is grey (no sunshine, or day or night), motionless and being stuck inbetween, suggesting she is trying to discover who she is as she is confused and lost in an emotionless haze.
As the images repeat the lighting gets brighter making the atmosphere more tranquil with the blues. These colours suggest daytime and a movement of time. The last line from the last stanza is, "in the shadow of your heart" which could mean that she is always going to be behind this man whom she loves- always be with him. This suggests a happy ending to the sad beggining, about loving someone who may not love you in return.
The ending shots are of the light bulb flashing to the sound similar to a heart-beat. This shows that the narrative has gone in a full cirle.
A similar aspect in both music videos (foals - Spanish sahara, and Florence and the machine- cosmic love) is hurt and sorrow. The endings of both songs could have similar meanings as in spanish sahara it is about moving on and not letting bad things keep you depressed, and in cosmic love it tells a story of unrequited love how fairytales can happen in real life.
Both music videos have only one character, in cosmic love it is a woman and in spanish sahara it is a man. This could show the stereotypes for indie music, as in music videos an aspect of the genre is singing but not in a live performance but in the narrative, making the lyrics amplify the on-screen action. In cosmic love, florence is seen dancing which a characteristic used by female artists and bands.
The camera shots in cosmic love is manly medium shots, panning, fade in-out, and zoom in-out. The shots are similar to that in spanish sahara except from spanish sahara has many close-ups of the character.
Good - some excellent detailed analysis of shots and narrative of video. You need to comment directly on how the artist is being represented and how the video appeals to audience.
ReplyDelete